Skip to main content

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies

 Oh my goodness. 

Whenever I eat a mini-Reese's cup, it's always a small blast from the past for me. It didn't matter if it was from my Easter basket, Halloween candy bag, or Christmas stocking - I always went for the Reese's cups first when I was young. I guess that last part is a lie. It wasn't only when I was young - I still do the same thing! The Reese's cups are just a must for me sometimes. 

I couldn't wait to make these cookies. I'm a huge fan of peanut butter chocolate cookies - but basically smashing one of my favorite candy all over each one? Shut the front door! (I've always wanted to say that phrase aloud at the appropriate moment... these cookies were well-worth it in this context, I assure you). They've probably entered my top 3 favorite cookie list... of all time. I'm dead serious. There's something deeply wonderful about these gooey peanut butter packages of chocolate nirvana.

My absolute favorite part of this cookie was eating them right out of the oven. I've scalded my mouth more times than I can count on one hand doing this. (Same with pizza... I burn my mouth with the first bite, only to take another one right after). The peanut butter was so warm, it was oozing off of the cookies, and the warm chocolate melded perfectly with it's counterpart. Not only are the cookies covered in melty peanut butter cups, they are filled with peanut butter cups. Heaven help us. 


Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
makes about 2 dozen medium sized cookies

1 1/2 C + 2 T Flour
6 T cocoa
1/2 t baking soda
1/2 t salt
3/4 stick (6 T) unsalted butter, room temperature
1/4 C + 2 T creamy peanut butter
1/2 C sugar
1/2 C brown sugar
1 large egg
1 T vanilla extract
2 T milk
2 C coarsely chopped peanut butter cups - if you freeze the peanut butter cups for about 30 minutes, it will make them easier to chop and manage. 

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Spray cookie sheet with a bit of cooking spray. In a medium bowl, combine together the flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and salt. Set aside. With your electric stand mixer, combine the butter, peanut butter, and sugars. Beat on medium-high speed until fluffy (about 2 minutes). Add in the vanilla, egg, and milk. Blend until smooth. With the mixer on low speed, mix in the dry ingredients by 1/2 cup full at a time until incorporated. Add in 1 1/2 C of the chopped peanut butter cups (saving about 1/2 cup for later), and fold in gently. 

Roll about 3 T of dough into balls, gently roll one side of the ball into the chopped peanut butter cups (just so some of them stick), and then space the dough balls about 2 inches apart.  Bake about 10 minutes, rotating the pan halfway through baking. Let cool on baking sheet about 10 minutes to set (they might look soft, but don't worry, they'll settle). Transfer to a wire rack to cool. Store in an airtight container. 

Recipe adapted from Annie's Eats.

I've been featured!
Thank you!  
linking up here 


  1. These look amazing! I can't wait to try them!! Did you mean 3/4 of a stick of butter? 1/4 would only be 2 T. Just checking. I'm making my grocery list so that I can make these sometime this week.

    1. Ahhh!! Yes!! Thanks so much for catching that, Amelias! I can't wait for you to try them - If Boston likes cookies as much as Jake does, then he's gonna go crazy for these :)

  2. Hi there,

    We've recently launched the site where users can search through hundreds of thousands of recipes from American food sites and food blogs.

    We noticed that you have a great number of tasty recipes on your blog (url) and we would like to suggest you have a look at our Top Food Blogs section here:

    If you want to add your food blog to the list and have your recipes indexed on, all you have to do is follow the instructions here:

    Our concept is already live in Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Spain, and we deliver thousands of visitors to food blogs daily. Some of the top food blogs receive 20,000+ visitors from us on a weekly basis.

    Hopefully your food blog will be up there in the top!

    Warm regards,

  3. I too love Reese cups, I take them from my kids at Halloween. I am not ashamed of that either! Love these cookies, too! I'm going to have to try them out!

  4. Reese cups are my all time favorite - and baking with them is a BIG win in my book

  5. Okay yeah I totally need to make these. I have been loving on Reese's lately. Cookies are also my favorite. I can't wait to try these, I totally wish I was in your house when you made these! It's my first time being to your site, I found you over at Mandy's recipe box. Thanks for sharing this!

  6. Yum-my! These look so great.

    Warmly, Michelle

  7. Peanut butter cups is Dh's favorite. These would be great for father's day! I'd love it if you would like up to Fantastic Thursday. Hope to see you there.

  8. I absolutely adore Resse's PB cups. I think they, and butterfingers, are my favorite candies. These look so good. Thanks so much for sharing on Tout It Tuesday!

  9. Thanks for linking up to Strut Your Stuff Saturday with this delicious recipe!! We love anything with Reeses!! Come back soon!! -The Sisters

  10. I love Reese's! These cookies look amazing! Thanks for sharing at Showcase Your Talent Thursday!

  11. I absolutely love anything that has reeses in it! Yum looking cookies:-)

  12. how many peanut butter cups make 2 cups? Can't wait to make these.

  13. These cookies are a great idea and your blog is beautiful. I would love if you could link up to Thursday Food Fest at Smiles, Sarah

  14. Haha, I also love cookies out of the over. It is worth the burnt mouth :p
    These look perfect! Who can resist a peanut butter cup cookie?

    1. I don't know anyone who doesn't love the peanut butter chocolate combo! Thanks for visiting, Cathleen. I hopped over to your blog - so cute!!

  15. Yummy! You have some other recipes that look fabulous as well!

  16. I just found your blog through a friend. Killer work I must say.

  17. Just found your blog after you so sweetly visited mine..
    These are on the top of my to bake list - It's sometimes hard to get peanut butter cups over here but I always buy tonnes when I see them and these cookies look *Amazing*...Mmmmm scrummy! & defo worth a burnt mouth as holding back would be impossible xx


Post a Comment

Thank you for commenting, I love hearing from you!

Popular posts from this blog

Breaded Pork Chops

Cucumber Tea Sandwiches

Turkey Club Tortilla Pinwheels

Peanut Butter Buttercream

Modern Number Cakes

Fresh Strawberry Yogurt Cake

Cocoa Buttercream Frosting

Chocolate Daisy Cake

Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake

7-Layer Dip Tortilla Pinwheels